I’d like to start off with a question: What’s wrong with the Yankees?
And an answer: Nothing.
Entering the All-Star break, the New York Yankees sit in third place in the AL East. At 50-45, they sit 6 games behind the Boston Red Sox and 5.5 games back of the surprising Tampa Bay Rays.
In this article I will explain why I think the Yankees will still make the playoffs, and discuss some trade moves/additions they could make in the next part of the season.
The first reason is the most important. Last year at this time the Yankees were in an even worse position. Heading into the All-Star break last season they were 9.5 games behind the Red Sox and had a winning percentage of only .500, at 43-43.
They then went on to go 51-25 the rest of the season and win the wild card to qualify for the playoffs. They finished only 2 games behind the Red Sox.
This season the Yankees have a better record than last, and also are 3.5 games closer to the division leaders in the standings. They came back in the standings easily last year, so why not this year too?
Reason number two is the Tampa Bay Rays. The Rays have never won more than 70 games in a season and have finished something other than last (second to last) in the division only once in their franchise history.
While the Yankees have more experience than any other team as far as qualifying for the playoffs, the Rays have absolutely zero experience of playing meaningful games towards the end of the season.
The Rays also enter the All-Star break on a seven game losing streak. Despite the current margin, it would be very surprising for the Rays to end the season ahead of the Yankees in the standings.
In fact, the Rays should even help the Yankees catch their ultimate foe, the Red Sox. The Rays have swept the Red Sox at home this season thus far (6-0), and have a home series against the Sox late in the season. The Rays host Boston in a three game set from September 15-17. If Tampa Bay’s winning trend at home against the Red Sox continues, the Yankees could gain a lot of ground quickly on the Red Sox late in the season.
The third reason is pitching. This may come as a surprise, considering pitching is usually pointed to as the Yankees most glaring weakness. Post All-Star break, their pitching will be better; and here’s why:
Joba Chamberlain has a 2.81 ERA through 41.1 innings pitched as a starter. He will only get better as he gets accustomed to his starting role and will emerge as the ace of this staff.
Mike Mussina and Andy Pettite are both extremely experienced pitchers, and have posted double-digit wins and ERA’s under 4 so far.
Chien-Ming Wang is the arguably the most reliable pitcher on the Yankees staff. He has an 8-2 record and an ERA just over 4. Amazingly, he has given up only four home runs this year in 95.0 innings.
That is four solid starting pitchers the Yankees will use for the rest of the season. The fifth and final spot belongs to Sidney Ponson for the time being. Ponson is an accomplished pitcher who has performed reasonably well in his first three starts as a Yankee. Ponson has had some struggles at this point in his career, so the Yankees are sure to keep a sharp eye on him for his next few starts.
Should Ponson falter in the slightest, expect the Yankees to make a deal for another starting pitcher. While big names like Harden and Sabathia have already been traded, there are several good pitchers the Yankees could still go after. This includes Cleveland’s Paul Byrd, Toronto’s A.J. Burnett, Seattle’s Erik Bedard, and Washington’s Tim Redding. It would be in the Yankees best interest to get another young pitching prospect in the long term, but for the short term they just need another reliable arm to send out to the mound.
Also, the Yankee bullpen is one of the best in the game. Mariano Rivera is still a lights out closer. He has 26 saves and a miniscule 1.06 ERA.
Kyle Farnsworth is a tall, hard throwing right-hander that is very difficult to score runs off of. His ERA is a little high at 3.51, but he has added approximately 1.45 wins to the Yankees cause thus far (measured by WPA, or Win Probability Added).
Jose Veras and Edwar Ramirez have also been very successful in the Yankee bullpen; both have ERA’s under 3.
With a fantastic closer and three very good relievers, the Yankee bullpen should have no trouble through the end of the season and into the playoffs.
Derek Jeter is my fourth reason. While he is the starting shortstop for the AL in the upcoming All-Star game, Jeter’s statistics have been below his career mark across the board thus far. I expect him to have a big second half of the season.
Jeter is striking out far less this year than other year during his career, at only 11.8% of his at-bats. So his problem is certainly not putting the ball in play.
However, his batting average only on balls hit in play (BABIP) is far lower than his career average. Jeter’s BABIP to date this season is a modest .315. Compare this to .368 last year, .394 the year before, and a .356 BABIP for his career. In fact, the .315 mark would be the lowest for Jeter’s entire career if the season ended today.
A lower BABIP means that more of your hits are being successfully fielded. The only explanations for this is either Jeter is getting unlucky and hitting the ball right to fielders, or that his is mis-hitting balls. This would mean either his timing or contact point is slightly off, which would be a rather easy mechanical fix with enough work.
Since Jeter is the Yankee captain and has come up big when the Yankees have needed him most throughout his career, I expect Jeter would put the necessary work in to fix any of these problems. His BABIP should stabilize and move closer to his career mark of .356. This means his productivity will increase, and this should be (along with my next reason) enough to catalyze the Yankee offense into some explosive run production.
The fifth reason is injuries. While all teams deal with injuries, the Yankees have had four different starters injured during the first part of the season. Alex Rodriguez and Jorge Posada both missed significant time at the beginning part of the season, but have since returned to the lineup. The Yankees also currently have outfielders Johnny Damon and Hideki Matsui on the DL.
Damon and Matsui were both hitting well above .300 before their injuries. Damon is expected to return shortly after the All-Star break and the Yankees are hopeful to get Matsui back soon as well. Matsui has started rehab assignments after injuring his knee in June.
With a healthy lineup, the Yankees still pose the biggest offensive threat in baseball. The return of Damon and Matsui not only gives the Yankees two more very successful bats in their already potent lineup, but it allows them to stop using Melky Cabrera in a starting role.
Cabrera has been the Yankees least productive position player by far this season. Melky has 356 at bats and only a .244 average. He also has a WPA (win probability added) of -1.6, which means he has cost the Yankees approximately 1.6 wins already this season. Cabrera has seen a decline in most of his statistics over his few years with the Yankees, so there is not a lot of hope for significant improvement in the second half of the season.
If any other injuries come up, or even if they don’t, I wouldn’t be surprised if the Yankees try to trade for another hitter as well. Jason Giambi has been having a fantastic season, but they could use someone who could play first base and/or DH, and maybe more importantly a utility fielder. Someone that could play second base to spell Robinson Cano, who is the next least productive Yankee behind Cabrera, and someone to fill in the outfield for injured players as needed.
Unfortunately for the Yankees, there are not many of these type players considered to be on the trading market right now. But the Yankees seem to always find ways of making rich enough offers to lure the players that they want.
Finally, the last reason I’m going to give why the Yankees will come back to make the playoffs is Yankee Stadium. Yankee Stadium as we know it is going to be demolished after this season. There is simply too much tradition, spirits, and memories that lie within the confines of Yankee Stadium to not give way to one last chance at baseball’s highest crown.
The Yankees have made the playoffs every year in recent memory, and there is no reason to think this year will be any different. Catching the Red Sox may prove difficult, especially after Boston finally broke through to win the division last year (first non-Yankee AL East Champion since 1997).
However, the Yankees will certainly give the Sox a run for their money. And if they fail to win the division, the Wild Card team from the American League has traditionally come out of the AL East as well in the modern era. The Yankees should have no problem locking up the second position in the division.